One of the best ways 
to stay ahead of risk? Stay well informed.

Home  /  Insights  /  Compliant Isn’t the Same as Defensible: What ERISA Asks of Plan Sponsors

Compliant Isn’t the Same as Defensible: What ERISA Asks of Plan Sponsors

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

Key Takeaways

  • Compliant means the filings are current and testing passed. Defensible means you can show how a decision was made.
  • A plan can be fully compliant and still have no documented process behind it.
  • Fiduciary class-action filings have escalated sharply and aren’t a large-plan-only risk anymore. None of the five markers of a defensible plan depend on investment performance.
Documents, contract and business people reviewing ERISA fiduciary process compliance

Here are two retirement plans:

The first files on time, passes every nondiscrimination test, and has never generated a complaint from a participant or a question from a regulator.

The second couldn’t produce a coherent account of how its investment lineup was chosen, who chose it, or what criteria it was measured against.

These are frequently the same plan.

The Standard Nobody Explained

Under ERISA, plan fiduciaries aren’t judged on whether the plan performed well. They’re judged on whether they followed a prudent, documented process.

That single sentence reframes most of what plan sponsors assume about their obligations. You aren’t required to select investments that outperform. You aren’t penalized for a fund that lagged. What you’re required to do is be able to demonstrate how you selected it, that you monitored it against stated criteria, and what you did when it stopped meeting them.

Which means compliance and defensibility are different tests, and clearing the first doesn’t imply the second.

What That Looks Like in Practice

A plan with correct filings and no Investment Policy Statement.

A plan that passes testing every year and has no committee minutes.

A plan with a fee that looks reasonable and has never been compared to anything.

A plan with three years of quarterly performance reports and no record that anyone read them.

None of those is a violation. All of them are gaps between what the plan does and what the plan can show.

Why This Stopped Being Theoretical

For most of the last two decades, fee and process litigation was a large-plan concern. Sponsors of plans in the single-digit millions could reasonably treat the documentation question as good practice rather than exposure.

That reading no longer holds. Fiduciary class-action filings reached 155 in 2025, and early 2026 filings have run well above the pace of the prior two years. The plaintiffs’ bar has worked out that documentation gaps are widespread below the large-plan market, and that they aren’t difficult to infer from a public Form 5500.

The practical implication isn’t that every mid-sized plan is about to be sued. It’s that the cost of not being able to show your process has gone up.

What a Governed Plan Looks Like

Five things are true of a plan that could withstand the question, and none of them require unusual sophistication.

  1. All-in cost is known, in basis points, and benchmarked on a defined cycle.
  2. Fiduciary roles are explicit and documented, and the sponsor knows precisely what they retain.
  3. Investment decisions follow a written process, and the process is evidenced rather than just the outcome.
  4. Plan design is revisited when the business changes, not when something breaks.
  5. Participants receive education rather than an annual enrollment meeting.

Notice that none of those is about investment performance.

Compliance is the floor. Defensibility is the bar. The distance between them isn’t a legal abstraction, it’s a set of documents that either exist or don’t.

Marshall+Sterling Wealth Advisors, Inc. is a registered investment adviser. Marshall+Sterling Wealth Advisors, Inc. does not provide tax or legal services. This article is educational and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice.

Frequently Asked Questions About ERISA Fiduciary Process

Are ERISA fiduciaries judged on investment performance?

No. Fiduciaries are judged on whether they followed a prudent, documented process. Strong or weak investment results don’t by themselves establish that the standard was met or missed.

Can a compliant retirement plan still carry fiduciary risk?

Yes. A plan can file on time and pass all testing while lacking the documentation needed to demonstrate how decisions were made, which is the standard fiduciaries are measured against.

A Short Review Tells You Whether Your Plan Is Defensible, Not Just Compliant. Find Out if Your Plan Would Hold Up:

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)
Email(Required)
Briefly describe your risk or insurance objectives.